large wild red shrimp split try them steamed with Old Bay Seasoning or famous voodoo style
$
Calamari
fried golden brown, with fried banana peppers and lemon aioli
$11.99
Crab & Spinach Dip
blue crab, fresh spinach, and cream cheese baked and topped with cheddar jack with freshly cooked corn tortilla chips
$12.99
Boom Boom Shrimp Bites
wild caught red shrimp deep fried & tossed in our spicy boom boom sauce
$12.99
Coconut Shrimp Bites
wild caught red shrimp, hand-breaded with a pina colada dipping sauce
$12.99
Fried Pickle Chips
hand-breaded with our remoulade sauce
$9.99
Crab Cake
large Florida style cake loaded with lump crab meat with pepper jam sauce
$12.99
Conch Fritters
six house-made conch fritters, lightly fried, with honey mustard
$12.99
Gator Bites
Florida caught, hand-breaded with fried banana peppers and remoulade sauce
$13.99
Bavarian Pretzel
jumbo, lightly salted pretzel with chorizo queso
$11.99
Avocado & Shrimp Ceviche*
our house-made ceviche topped with avocado chunks, served with tortilla chips
$11.99
Boneless Chicken Wings
buffalo style with choice of ranch or blue cheese
$11.99
Chips & Chorizo
house-made kettle chips topped with blackened chicken, chorizo queso, sour cream, and green onions
$12.99
Shell Bar
Oysters Rockafellar*
gulf oysters topped with creamy crab & spinach dip, bacon and hollandaise sauce.
$
Garlic Mussels
cold water mussels sautéed in garlic butter and white wine, with garlic bread.
$12.99
Crabby's Baked Oysters
topped with garlic butter, parmesan cheese, and house seasonings.
$
Soup & Salads
Clam Chowder
Try our World Famous original recipe loaded with hearty potatoes, freshly shucked clams, bacon, and house spices
$5.99
Calamari Caesar Salad
a classic caesar salad topped with crispy calamari and fried cherry peppers, with garlic bread
$16.99
Avocado Shrimp Salad*
crisp spinach mixed with homemade mango salsa, pico de gallo, citrus marinated shrimp, banana chips, topped with sliced avocado, and paired with a mango pineapple vinaigrette
$15.99
House Salad
romaine and spring mix blend, topped with tomatoes, onions, croutons, and cheddar jack cheese
$6.99
Classic Caesar Salad
topped with grated parmesan cheese and croutons
$7.99
Salad Protein Add-Ons
$8.99
Boils!
Crab & Shrimp
3/4lb Bairdi crab legs and 1/2 order of easy peel shrimp with corn on the cob, smoked sausage, and tossed in cajun or garlic sauce
$
Seafood Feast
1.5lbs of Bairdi crab legs and a full order of easy peel shrimp with corn on the cob, smoked sausage, and tossed in cajun or garlic sauce
$
Shrimp
a full pound of wild red shrimp, smoked sausage, and fresh corn tossed in cajun or garlic sauce
$
Crab
Bairdi crab legs with corn on the cob and smoked sausage, and tossed in cajun or garlic sauce
$
Add
Add 1/2lb of scallops to any boil
$
Combo Platters
Key West Combo
grilled mahi and large wild red shrimp glazed with key lime honey mustard, with conch fritters
$25.99
Steak & Crab Combo*
14oz Chairman's reserve cut New York strip and 3/4lb of Crab legs
$
Steak & Shrimp Combo*
14oz Chairman's reserve cut New York strip and shrimp scampi
$36.99
Grouper and Shrimp
a fresh cut filet of grouper and 8 royal red shrimp grilled or fried
$31.99
Crabby's Combo
a fried trip of grouper nuggets, calamari and wild caught royal red shrimp
$28.99
Onshore
Loaded Chicken
twin chicken breasts basted in sweet honey bbq and topped with bacon, onions and cheddar jack cheese
$15.99
New York Strip*
a 14oz Chairman's reserve cut, topped with garlic butter
$28.99
Chicken Strips
hand breaded with choice of sauce
$14.99
Offshore
Red Gulf Grouper
A local favorite. Served fried, grilled, blackened, or Caribbean style
$
Wild Red Shrimp
prepared grilled and skewered or lightly dusted and fried
$18.99
Mahi Mahi
warm water fillet, served grilled, blackened, or Caribbean style
$
Bairdi Crab
A house favorite! served traditional steamed or fire-roasted with garlic butter and old bay seasoning. 1.5 lbs
$
Fish & Chips
panko crusted Alaskan cod filets with sea salt and a malt vinegar mist
$18.99
Ahi Tuna Steak*
blackened medium-rare, with a side of our house made cusabi sauce
$17.99
Baked Scallops
panko crusted and topped with imperial sauce
$18.99
Coconut Triple Tail
hand breaded in Malibu coconut breading and fried golden brown to perfection
$25.99
Coconut Shrimp
hand-breaded jumbo wild reds with our sweet pepper jam
$
Red Snapper
lightly blackened, with our homemade key lime tartar sauce
$
Sandwiches
Fresh Gulf Grouper
fried, grilled, blackened, or caribbean style
$
Mahi Mahi
grilled, blackened, or Caribbean style
$14.99
Pacific Rim Tuna*
ahi tuna fillet, seared, topped with a cusabi drizzle over baby greens, sesame ginger, on toasted ciabatta
$15.99
Salmon BLT
thinly sliced smoked salmon, delicious thick cut bacon, with lettuce and tomato, served on a toasted ciabatta roll
$15.99
Grouper Sliders
3 beer battered grouper cheeks with pickles and house made key lime tartar
$11.99
Sirloin Burger*
1/2 lb of hand-pattied angus beef and brisket blend
$11.99
Avocado Turkey Burger*
chargrilled, low-fat, high protein, premium ground turkey, topped with sliced avocado on a ciabatta roll
$11.99
Buffalo Chicken
fried and tossed in a spicy buffalo sauce
$11.99
Crab Cake
hand-pattied jumbo lump crab cake served with lemon aioli
$
Tacos
Florida Grouper
lightly fried grouper, fresh cabbage, cheddar cheese, topped with a spicy baja sauce and a house-made salsa verde
$
Tropical Mahi Mahi
blackened mahi mahi, shredded cabbage, mango salsa, topped with cheddar cheese and a homemade cilantro cream sauce
$15.99
Boom Boom Shrimp
fried shrimp tossed in boom boom sauce placed on top sweet pickled cabbage
$16.99
Chicken
fried chicken fingers, fresh cabbage, cheddar cheese, topped with a spicy baja sauce and a house-made salsa verde
$13.99
Avocado
fried avocado, cabbage, carrots, cilantro aioli
$11.99
Pastas
Shrimp Pasta
large wild red shrimp and linguine pasta tossed in our creamy alfredo sauce
$18.99
Cajun Pasta
linguine pasta tossed in a creamy cajun sauce with grilled chicken & smoked sausage, topped with Parmesan cheese
$17.99
Shrimp & Grits
sauteed large wild red shrimp, smoked sausage, and piquillo peppers over cheesy grits
$18.99
Chicken & Grits
blackened chicken, smoked sausage, and piquillo peppers over cheesy grits
$16.99
Sides
Fries
$
Cheesy Grits
$
Black Beans & Rice
$
House-Made Kettle Chips
$
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
$
Fresh Veggie
$
1/2 Ear Fresh Corn
(seasonal availability)
$
Coleslaw
$
Caribbean Street Corn
$2.99
Mac & Cheese
$1.99
Desserts
Killer Key Lime Pie
Key West authentic award winning pie
$
Sweet Willy's Ice Cream
Named after our founder's daughter Sylvia, who was given the nickname Willy. Ask about our small-batched rotating flavors! Flavors for your four-legged friends available too!
$
Ice Cream Sandwich
Two large Otis Spunkmeyer chocolate chip cookies with a vanilla ice cream center
$
Mainland
Chicken Fingers
$5.99
Grilled Chicken
$5.99
Mac and Cheese
$5.99
Hamburger or Cheeseburger
$5.99
Alfredo Pasta
$5.99
Seafood
Grilled Fish
$6.99
Fried Shrimp
$6.99
Fish Fingers
$6.99
Drinks on Tap
Rum Runner
A delicious blend of Cruzan Rum, blackberry brandy, creme de banana and tropical juices.
$
Margarita Bucket
Our classic margarita made with Hornitos Tequila.
$
Frozen Favorites
Key Lime in the Coconut
We put the lime in the coconut and shake it all about, made with Cruzan Key Lime and a Plantation Dark Rum floater.
$
Dirty Banana
Cruzan Rum, creme de cacao, Kahlua, banana puree, chocolate drizzle, and topped with a Plantations Dark Rum floater
$
Perfect Pina Colada
Cruzan Coconut Rum, a vastly refreshing coconut mix, and a Plantation Dark Rum floater.
$
Florida Sunset
Hornitos Tequila blended with triple sec and our famous mango mix. Layered atop our strawberry mix and topped with a tequila floater to create the perfect Florida Sunset.
$
Thunder Juice
Be the thunder! With this beverage of champions! Tito's Vodka blended with lemonade, blue curacao, and the secret to winning.
$
Beamsicle
Kentucky meets Florida with this Jim Beam Orange infused frozen favorite. A crafty twist on the traditional dreamsicle.
$
Coastal Cocktails
Coconut Mojito
Cruzan Coconut Rum with fresh squeezed lime juice, mint, simple syrup and a splash of soda.
$
Strawberry Lemonade Mojito
Frankly Organic Strawberry Vodka mixed with fresh muddled lemons, mint leaves, strawberries, lemonade, and a splash of soda
$
Twisted Lemonade
Get twisted! Our classic Titos Lemonade infused with a Twisted Tea bottle.
$
Florida Sunshine
A bright delicious drink mixed with Hornitos Tequila, Coconut Rum, fresh lime juice and mango puree mix.
$
Orange Crush
Nothing says summer like Natalie's Organic Orange juice, paired with orange Vodka, triple sec and a splash of lemon lime soda.
$
1848 Hurricane
This cocktail is as strong as the Great Hurricane of 1848 that created John's Pass. Be careful with this one!
$
Ritas & Grias!
Dosarita
a 12oz Dos Equis Lager turned face down in a Crabby's Classico Margarita. Best of both worlds! Stay thirsty!
$
Organic Margarita
Fresh from the earth with Tres Agaves tequila and all organic blend of Margarita goodness
$
Casamigos Top Shelf
Casamigos Tequila with fresh lime juice, agave nectar, organic margarita mix, and topped with a Grand Marnier float.
$
Dragon Fruit
A blend of Tres Generaciones, organic margarita mix with muddled limes and dragon fruit.
$
White Peach
A refreshing light sangria with fresh strawberries and Monin White Peach.
$
Red Sangria
Classic sangria with cinnamon, fresh orange juice, blackberry brandy, red wine.
$
Crabby's Beer
Bottles & Cans
$
Drafts
$
Wines
House Wines by Woodbridge
$
Josh Cellars
Premium Wines
$
Specials
Dragon Fruit Rum Punch
Key West's Pilar Rum shaken with a tropical dragon fruit juice blend
$
Short Rib Mac
slow cooked short rib baked in white cheddar mac and cheese topped with toasted panko.
$
Cold Lobster Roll
pulled Maine lobster gently tossed in Hellman's Mayo and served on a grilled hot dog roll with choice of side
$
Shrimp Ravioli
red shrimp, smoked sausage, piquillo peppers, and cheese ravioli in a burgundy cream sauce with garlic bread
$
Cajun Combo
domestic flounder and red shrimp hand breaded in cajun flour and served with 2 sides
$
Blueberry Cheesecake
Two award winning desserts in 1 bite! Mike's blueberry pie and NY cheesecake in his gluten free graham cracker crust.
$
iBuenos Dias!
Huevos Rancheros
two crispy corn tortillas, black beans, pico de gallo, cheese, two cage free eggs and ranchero salsa drizzle.
$12.99
Breakfast Tacos
three tacos filled with scrambled eggs, cheddar jack cheese, and bacon. Served with pico de gallo and sour cream
$12.99
Chilaquiles
tortilla chips simmered in salsa verde topped with two cage free eggs, shredded queso blanco, and diced avocado
$12.99
Egg White Tacos
these tacos are no yolk! three tacos filled with egg whites, spinach, tomatoes, avocado slices and topped with salsa verde, with a side of fresh fruit
$14.99
Bennies & Sandwiches
Crabby Benedict
grilled crab cakes, poached eggs, fresh spinach, on a toasted English muffin with our benedict sauce.
$16.99
Eggs Benedict
grilled country ham, poached eggs, fresh spinach, on a toasted English muffin with our benedict sauce.
